Offtake Agreement Optimisation – How to Minimise Value Leakage

You have finalised your Bankable Feasibility Study (BFS) (or in some cases Feasibility Study) and are moving into financing mode. Depending on the market cycle, you may be either batting away financier interest with a stick, or out there banging the drum, or somewhere in between. You may be part way through the process and getting tired of balancing your day job with managing Q&A rounds and site visits, your team fatigued from data room requests. You just want to get the financing closed.

Capital is king (lifeblood even) and will move you into the next phase, production is in sight. So, when a draft offtake agreement lands in your inbox, you want to get it done, a key condition precedent to financial close and draw down squared away.

However, this is not the time to take your foot off the scrutiny pedal. As we know, offtake agreement terms dictate the revenue your project will earn and one of the two determinants of the net margin you/your shareholders will (eventually) bank. Ensuring you optimise primary and secondary commercial terms now can have a huge impact on cashflow and asset returns down the track, especially if the offtake agreement is beyond five years.

Here are some areas to focus on to maximise your offtake margins:

  • If time is on your side, use it!
  • Understand the off-taker’s working capital access and how this could benefit you
  • Don’t ignore off-spec products and how terms propose to deal with these scenarios when they present
  • Bear in mind the big-picture financing and consider how the off-take terms enhance or hinder these
  • For long term contracts, consider price review provisions to ensure terms remain in step with market.
  1. Time can be in your favour – if you are operating in a competitive part of the price cycle with your product in high demand, the Off taker will be focusing on inking the agreement quickly to secure production before other competitors, and to meet their internal KPIs. If this is the case, time is on your side, and you can utilise this to negotiate more amenable secondary terms in your agreement. For example, ensuring that the force-majeure provisions are balanced, and not just in favour of the off taker. You do not want to be penalised for events beyond your control.
  2. Off takers (traders, end user customers) can often access working capital at very competitive rates. Take time to understand their working capital access. You can benefit from this whilst negotiating your payment terms. For example, rather than receipt of funds 30 days post Free on Board (FOB) sale, reducing this by circa 15 days can make a big difference to your cashflows and should be far from a deal breaker for your counter party. Your cash flow cycle will be healthier for it, particularly over the ramp up period. Off takers also have access to competitively priced supply chain financing or invoice discounting facilities, which can be offered to the producer at competitive rates.
  3. Define detailed quality specifications and tolerance levels as well as how these will be measured and tested. Consider negotiating limitations on the off-taker’s ability to reject for small deviations, instead negotiate remediations or discounts. Tolerance and rejection limits can have an outsized impact on cashflow and margins when production quality challenges present from time to time.
  4. Keep future capital raise plans in mind when negotiating the term and quantum of your offtake agreement to maximise your future pool of financiers. For example, providing life of mine (LOM) and 100% of production terms may lock out a number of debt and equity providers where securing offtake production is a requirement for financing. Default and consent clauses are also important here. As you know, an offtake can itself be a source of financing, so if you are getting some finance from the off taker in exchange of giving them the offtake, make sure that the terms of the off-taker financing do not impede or prevent you from accessing the larger financing from commercial lenders. Commercial lenders do not like terms such as off taker’s right of set-off in the offtake agreement and would require you to amend the offtake terms to remove or restrict these.
  5. If the tenor of your offtake is long – circa 5 years – allow for price renegotiations and adjustments. For example, an annual pricing structure review to ensure the original pricing principal remains intact.

At Tate Advisory we are passionate about offtake optimisation. It’s an area we are well versed in, with our team experienced on both sides of the desk. For a comprehensive view and guidance on how you can optimise your offtake agreement negotiations.